The Woman I Once Was -- Mango Street -- Lindsey Dawkins
House
on Mango Street is one of those books that ends up covered in pencil marks,
underlines, hearts, and exclamation points, because the sheer volume of
wonderful words and things that show up in it is almost overwhelming. Even
though not all of us are immigrants or from a culture that is a minority, I
think this book has a little something for everyone. For me, however, the most
captivating part of the entire book is the Introduction.
The very
name of the Introduction kind of frontloads the entire concept of the rest of
the vignettes. “A House of My Own” tells the reader that the “House on Mango
Street” isn’t the only house this author has identified as her own space. I
love the distinction between the two settings, and I love that it is developed
right from the beginning. I think we can all understand early on that just like
there are two important “houses” there are two important people in the book. Cisneros’
identity is largely tied to her home, which I think is a universal theme. Her
identity truly comes into itself when she gets her own apartment, and I think
that is also something that is undeniably true. Cisneros’ writes that the space
is somewhere for her to “look and think”, which is vital to anyone (xii). Kind
of makes sense why teenagers are so adamant about their own rooms, huh?
The tense
of the Introduction is third person in many places, and I think this creates a
powerful effect. For example, Cisneros’ writes “She’s trying to live like a
writer” (xv). This sentence alone breaks the fourth-wall. A writer is reflecting
on herself, and writing about herself trying to live like a writer. The third
person tense is something one would expect in a typical novel, and It’s a fascinating
shout-out to writing as a career. I think the switch between third and first
person also helps the reader to distinguish between the two “women” in the
Introduction, because there is most certainly two of them. Cisneros’ refers to
herself as “the woman I once was” which implies that the woman in the photo is
not the woman writing the introduction (xvii). The illustration of identity
development and change is something that I find to be inspiring and relevant to
adolescents, and even those of us in what I like to refer to as “adultolescence.”
I think the
Introduction alone is a vital part of the book. Without it, I don’t think we
would be able to understand how these experiences of Cisneros’ and those she
knew (knows) influenced her vignettes. The appearance of her mother in the
introduction makes the vignette “Hairs” all the more powerful, because by the
time we get to “Hairs” in the novel, we know that Mother is an important figure,
and one that meant a lot to Cisneros’. The Introduction ends in a memoriam for
her mother, and I think it’s telling that a series of vignette’s all about
development, true self, and the search for self is started with a shout-out to
where it all began; her mama.
This is by
far and large my favorite we have read so far. Cisneros’ structure and
beautiful imagery is something that I can see, smell, hear, and almost touch if
I try hard enough. I think it’s words like these that matter the most, and Cisneros’
truly do touch the soul.
This is by far and large my favorite blog. I love the passion in this. I could not agree more. "Haris" is so powerful and it truly does begin with her mama. The introduction is my favorite part too. I love the passage that tells of her father's dreams for her. To be a weather girl, or get married and have babies. I couldn't tell you how many times I've been asked, "When are you going to have one?", so I absolute love her response to his close-minded future for his daughter. "Jump out of a cake." (xv) made me laugh out loud. Wonderful post !!!
ReplyDeleteLindsey, it really is important to note that there is a difference in "house" and "home" and I think you do an excellent job of portraying that through this! Your focus on the introduction actually got me to go back and read it and experience it for myself, so I certainly have to thank you for that!
ReplyDeleteLindsay, you did an amazing job conveying the different ideas that manifested in House on Mango Street! When I first started reading the novel I was amazed at how well Cisneros constructed it and her writing style is absolutely amazing! I agree that this is one of the best YA novels that I have read. Great job constructing this blog post
ReplyDelete